
I love this book.
Forgive this digression. Reading this tonight I was struck by the connections with other works represented here. Earlier I noticed in the preface to
The God Delusion that Dawkins gave thanks "for a variety of reasons" to Daniel Dennett and Sam Harris. In
Breaking the Spell, Dennett, unsurprisingly, cites Dawkins frequently (particularly, though not exclusively, his idea of "memes"). His mention of kleptocracy merely reminded me of Jared Diamond, while the book is elsewhere replete with direct references to Diamond, whom he calls, along with others, "[t]he pioneers whose scientific work on religion I have been introducing." At another point this evening I unintentionally placed Dennett's book next to Hofstadter's
Godel, Ecsher and Bach; something clicked, and I remebered that Dennett and Hofstadter collaborated as editor's of
The Mind's I, a collection of essays about consciousness. Then, as if to deliberately create a longing for books not yet completed, Dennett's discussion of Wittgenstein foreshadowed another work I will later suggest to the group (and currently located on my night table). Later in the evening, I read Dennett's attack on the "mysterian
" doctrine that insists that consciousness is not a
puzzle but rather a
mystery. This is exactly the dichotomy discussed in Malcolm Gladwell's fascinating and contrarian article this past week about Enron (and to which I do not yet have a link, but you can borrow my copy of the
New Yorker). OK, I'm done now. Oh, wait: did I mention Dennett's reference to those great American non-believers, Franklin and Paine . . .